Carvana Wants to Buy Your Car: Should Retailers Be Concerned?

Carvana wants to buy your car

With Carvana’s advertising push to buy your car – no trade attached, the automotive darling startup has once again staked its claim against the traditional dealership experience. “We don’t play dealership games” is the mantra. And while the company is still not profitable, pivots like this garner attention.

Is Carvana an Industry Disruptor?

In a recent conversation, auto industry veteran Ed French responds, “Absolutely! Carvana is a disruptor,” when asked if franchise dealers should be concerned about this play.

French says, “This new acquisition strategy is purely a play to get a cost advantage. They’ve had to go to the street like everybody else but they haven’t had the luxury of new car franchises to acquire trades. They’re having to acquire them through normal traditional channels, and there’s just no juice in that squeeze.”

Carvana presently burns about $50M a quarter. The startup sold approximately 100,000 cars in 2018, but it wants to be selling 2M cars a year within the next 2-3 years. In order to do this, it’s going to need inventory, and it will of course have to be in business. With an average loss of $800 per car, according to French, Carvana must find a way to not only acquire more vehicles, but be more profitable.

Video Preview

Follow the Leader

And who best to look to than the undisputed leader in used cars – Carmax. In contrast, Carmax in 2018 sold more than 770k vehicles. And it profits about $200M each quarter according to a 2018 press release. The nearly 30 year old company buys EVERYTHING. And with more than 200 locations nationwide, one advantage Carmax has over all others is its wholesale platform.

Wholesale Platform

According to French, Carmax wholesales about 100,000 cars a year, internally and externally. And profitability on its wholesale business is “outstanding.” The reason why is because Carmax retail outlets have the ability to wholesale vehicles from location to location without the typical auction costs that its competitors face.

Carvana sees this, and understands that it too must enable itself with the same advantage if it’s going to compete and be profitable.

Simplifying the Sale

On the surface, Carvana’s big message to consumers is that they provide not just an alternative to the traditional dealership experience, but a better experience all together. This applies not only to buying a car, but also selling your car to Carvana. As described on its blog:

In addition to providing car buying customers with an online solution to purchasing and trading in their vehicles, we also allow customers to sell their vehicles outright without the stress, anxiety, and time spent that comes with attempts to sell privately or to a dealership.

While there is truth to the idea that doing business with dealers is considered worse than a root canal, it is only marketing rhetoric. If Carvana wants to profit, which it must, then it can’t risk offering more on vehicles than they are worth. In that sense, they can’t compete on price, only on customer experience, which is something all dealers have the ability to compete on as well.


About the Author

Ryan G
Ryan Gerardi is Chief Editor of AutoConverse Magazine and Executive Producer and Host of the AutoConverse Podcast and Live Weekly Broadcast. He is also Founder & CEO of AutoConversion with nearly 20 years experience in the automotive industry. Ryan concentrates his efforts today on exploring people, ideas, and technologies related to how we get around and how we are connected.